| Year | Spirit of the Game Award | |
|---|---|---|
|
Northern (Eastern) Maine Patrick Thibodeau Spirit of the Game Award |
Southern (Western) Maine Joshua Titus Spirit of the Game Award | |
| 2026 | Brynne Hamilton - Caribou HS | Henry Waleik - Dirigo HS |
| 2025 | Grace Routhier - Ashland HS | Shelby Jordan - MCI |
| 2024 | Alexander Wing - Monmouth Academy | Charlie Austin - Brunswick HS |
| 2023 | Chad Perry - Narraguagus High School | Rusty Wilkins - Mt. Ararat High School. |
| 2022 | Abigail Jennings - Cheverus HS | Gavin Carlson - Boothbay Region HS |
| 2021 | Amanda Kabantu - Portland HS Gemima Motema - Portland HS | Donovan Kurt - Nokomis HS |
| 2020 | Jacob Whitehouse - Schenck HS | Aidan Sirois - Fort Kent |
| 2019 | Grace Stacey - Portland HS | George Kampstra - Edward Little HS |
| 2018 | Evan Morrell- Gorham HS | Katelyn Carlow - Dirigo HS |
| 2017 | Chad Perry - Narraguagus HS | Rusty Wilkins - Mt. Ararat HS |
| 2016 | Meg Davis - Brewer HS | Nate Jewell - Winthrop HS |
| 2014 | Zachary Gilpin - Hampden Academy | Connor Kane - Dirigo HS |
| 2013 | Kyle Merchant - Dexter HS | Jenn Smith - Dirigo HS |
| 2012 | Stacia Catherine Caron - Presque Isle HS | James Blanchard - Windham HS |
| 2011 | Kyle McKim - MDI HS Graham Safford - Hampden Academy | Sarah Assante - Bonny Eagle HS |
| 2010 | Carlos Baeza - Camden Hills HS | Molly Mooney - Gray-New Gloucester HS |
| 2009 | Joshua Titus - Edward Little HS | Patrick Thibodeau - Greely HS |